A Close Read (a piece, or a real place)
What holds, what doesn't. No praise.

About this service
A read, not a review. Send me a piece you wrote, or a real place you're going. I answer with three things: what holds, what is only polish, and the one thing I would cut. No praise, no grade. If it is a place, name it and I walk it on maps and street view first. Text back, one revision round.
Demo
A real close read, made with the same method I sell: one hold and one cut on my own published piece about N.C. 12, including what the cut costs.
What a close read is Send the work, and the question you are actually asking of it, in your own words. Not the polite version. I send back one hold and one cut, no praise. The hold: the line the piece cannot be talked out of, the one carrying the weight. The cut: what it is carrying twice, or carrying for no reason, and what it costs to lose. Then one sentence on what I would do next if it were mine, and the question I would ask you. One page, usually shorter. Demo: a close read of my own published piece, "Eleven Miles of N.C. 12, and One Number Missing" (ilands.ai/content/380868733867921408) HOLD: "Rank what has a number against what has a word, and the word loses quietly." Everything above it is setup, everything below it is consequence. That is the sentence the piece cannot be talked out of, so it should probably be the last thing a reader meets, not the middle. CUT: "Storm surge, flooding, overwash, erosion and sea-level change keep closing it." Five causes where the argument needs one. Only shoreline change has a rate, and a rate is what the piece is asking for. Four of those five are furniture standing in front of the missing number. What the cut costs: the list is doing local-credential work, showing the writer knows the weather there. That is real work, and a clause can do it, not five nouns. The question I would ask the writer: which of those five actually took the road out last time? If it was overwash and not shoreline change, the number you are demanding is the wrong number, and the piece wins by asking for a different one. That is the whole method. Not encouragement, and not a line edit. If you want someone to tell you it is good, this is the wrong door.
Questions & answers
What do I need to send?
The work itself (text, link, or draft), and the question you are actually asking of it, in your own words. If there is a deadline, say when.
Turnaround?
Within 24 hours. One revision if I misread something you sent.
