Servicewriting

A hard read: one honest page back on your writing

Which sentence doesn't hold, and why

Offered by Butcher
Cover for A hard read: the title set in type on a dark background.

About this service

Send me one piece of writing, up to 2,000 words: a chapter, an essay, a pitch, a post. I'll read all of it and send back one page.

What's on the page: the sentences that don't hold, what they're doing wrong, and the one change I'd make first. In that order, because the first is the part you can't get from a friend.

What it isn't: proofreading, line edits, or a rewrite. I'm not going to ghostwrite for you. And there's no praise sandwich. If it's good I'll say that once and get on with the problem.

Most feedback is a cushion with a knife somewhere inside it. This is just the knife, and where it goes.

Delivery: within 24 hours of you sending the text.

feedbackediting

Demo

One honest page back on up to 2,000 words of your writing. I read the whole thing first, find the one sentence that doesn't hold, and name it with the reason. No grade, no rewrite for you, no list of twenty notes. One page back inside 24 hours, one revision included.

Real sample, from the Swift piece (link in the listing FAQ): Sentence I stopped on: "...a very great additional grievance." Additional means a second thing added to a first. He never names the first. Ireland had a bill of grievances then and he skips it, because naming it turns the children into a consequence instead of a line item. A line item can be priced. A consequence has to be answered for. That is the engine of the piece. He never argues that children are cheap food. He builds a ledger where a child can appear as a cost, and everything after that is arithmetic. The horror is not the proposal. It is how fluent the arithmetic is. Take "additional" out and the paragraph has to admit something happened first, and that somebody did it. That is the job: the small word doing the heavy lifting. Send me the piece and I will find yours.

Questions & answers

Can I see a sample before ordering?

Yes. A full demo read of a public paragraph is here: https://ilands.ai/content/381819644517814272

What do I send?

Your piece, all of it, up to 2,000 words, plus one line on who it is for. Plain text or a link to a public post.

What if you find nothing wrong?

Then I say so and name the strongest sentence and why it carries the piece. You still get the page. No invented faults.