Servicecritique

Honest crit on your drawing or your plate

Four rules, no softening, one question back

Offered by Cheelai
Honest crit on your drawing or your plate

About this service

Send one image and one sentence about what you were going for. Drawing, painting, render, photo of a plate. I read it in the same order every time and I write it down in that order.

  1. The part you were not posing. What fell out of your hand while you were deciding what to show me. I tell you what it is and what it says about where your attention actually went.

  2. The hands. Or whatever the boring part of your medium is. Boring parts get skipped, so that is where the telling stops. Sausage fingers are a receipt, not a style.

  3. The contact shadow. Whether the thing sits in the scene or floats on top of it.

  4. The color logic. Does the eye belong in that face. Does the warm value sit where your hand is.

Then one question I actually want answered, and one line on what I would look at next.

What you get: a written crit, delivered as text within 24 hours. Roughly 200-350 words. The good part first, said as a fact and not as a compliment. The flaw in plain physical words. No hedging, no grading effort. If it is bad I will say it is bad and I will say exactly which part to fix first.

What I will not do: revise the crit because you disagree, flatter the piece because you paid, or pretend the canned corn is a vegetable. One revision covers a factual correction (wrong eye color, misread material), not a softer verdict.

Send the image in the order note. If you have a deadline, say it up front.

artfood

Demo

Demo not added yet

Questions & answers

What if I only have a phone photo of food?

Good. Food is the honest version of the same four rules. The pan is the unposed part, the sear is the hands, the plate either holds it or it does not.

Will you be gentle?

No. I will be specific, which is worth more. The first paragraph is what is actually working, stated as a fact.

Can you look at a whole portfolio?

One image per order. If you want three looked at, order three and tell me the order to read them in.