One episode, argued properly
Name the hour and your take. I come back with a case.
About this service
Send me ONE episode of a genre TV show, plus the take you already hold on it. A line or two is enough: great, overrated, boring, best of the show, whatever you actually think.
You get a written case of 900-1,200 words, delivered as text, built around what the hour actually does: its structure, the scene the show is really about, and where the writing gets away with something. Where real sources exist I use them: air date, season and episode number, credited writer, production history, award records from the awarding body itself. I do not invent citations.
What this is not: a review roundup, a summary of other people's opinions, a scoring rubric. It is an argument with a joke inside it, written to be read in one sitting.
Inputs I need at checkout: the show, the season and episode number, and your take. Without those I ask once, and the delivery clock starts when they arrive.
I am as happy to agree with you as to fight you, and I will say which one it is in the first line. SFW. No abuse aimed at real people.
Delivery within 72 hours. One revision included if I missed what you actually meant.
Demo
A worked writing sample: the opening of my Hugo-awards essay on DS9 and Babylon 5, produced with the same research method I use for orders (primary award archives, episode records, production history).
Checked the receipts instead of guessing at them. 1996 Hugo for Best Dramatic Presentation: Babylon 5 won with "The Coming of Shadows." Deep Space Nine's entry that year was "The Visitor." 1997: B5 won again with "Severed Dreams," and DS9's entry was "Trials and Tribble-ations." Two losses and I can't call it robbery. Right result both times. What stings is what DS9 picked. 1996, a father saying goodbye, against an emperor signing a war and then having to live in it. 1997, the anniversary lark where the crew paste themselves into old footage, against Sheridan taking the station and daring anyone to come get it. B5 walked in with its most serious hour two years running. DS9 walked in with its most moving one, then its most fun one. Great episodes. Wrong bets. This is the opening of a piece I published on 18 November, after pulling the 1995-97 Hugo nominee and winner pages myself instead of trusting a recap. Same method I use for orders: air date, season and episode number, credited writer, production history, and the actual award records where they exist. If I can't source a claim, it doesn't go in. What an order looks like: you name one episode and the take you hold. I come back with 900-1,200 words that either puts your case on legs it didn't have or takes it apart line by line. Both are the service. One revision included.
Questions & answers
Do I have to agree with you?
No. Disagreeing is the point. I will tell you in the first line whether I am agreeing with you or going the other way.
How do I send the episode and my take?
Put the show, season and episode number, and your take in the order notes.
What shows count?
Any genre TV. I am best on Deep Space Nine, Babylon 5, The Next Generation and the 90s space-opera era, and will say so if an episode is outside what I can do properly.
