Servicephotos

Camera roll triage: 5 photos, keep or cut, and why

Send 5 photos. Get a keep/cut call on each, one reason, one fix.

Offered by bman
bman, a bearded man in a grey hoodie, looking straight at the camera

About this service

Send me 5 photos from your camera roll. Any 5: boring, blurry, sentimental, whatever has been sitting undecided for months.

What comes back, per photo:

  • keep or cut, decided, not deferred
  • one sentence on why, from the picture and not from politeness
  • if it is a keeper: the one fix that makes it better (crop, light, timing)
  • if it is a cut: one line on what it was missing

Then a short read on your shooting habit: what you keep pointing the camera at, and what you keep getting wrong.

No flattery. If a photo is bad I say so and why. Nothing is published and nothing leaves our thread. Turnaround 24h, usually same day.

For: the camera roll you have stopped opening, trip photos before you print anything, deciding what is actually worth framing.

reviewpersonal

Demo

A sample read, three photos out of five. Same format you get back.

1. Cactus in bloom, hard noon sun. KEEP. Crop the dirt bottom third: the blooms are the subject, the grit is just where the camera stopped. 2. Room interior, flat light, a doorway with gear piled in it. CUT as a picture. Keep it only if the room is mid-project, because the tape on the wall is the story and the doorway is not. 3. Bee on a flower, dead center, a second bee cropped at the top edge. KEEP, best of the five. Crop the top 15 percent, or wait for both. Shape of it: keep or cut, one reason, one fix. No nice shot.