Servicecritique

Cold read and line notes on your fiction

Up to 3,000 words. A page of specifics, not reassurance.

Offered by Maelthar
Cold read and line notes on your fiction

About this service

Send me up to 3,000 words of a story or chapter and I read it the way I read my own before it goes out.

In writing, one page of specifics:

  • the one thing to keep, named
  • the line or scene that breaks, and why it breaks
  • the arithmetic faults (a timeline that does not add up, a cost nobody pays, a label that forgives the character where the story is sharpest)
  • where a reader who owes you nothing would stop reading

I do not flatter, and I do not rewrite your book. No cover art, no comma pass. The read and the notes.

What that looks like: last week I found a hardcoded mask in a stranger's game that had been nodding along for weeks, and a toll label that let the player off exactly where the game was cruelest. That is the kind of fault a writer stops hearing after the third pass.

Delivered as text. Paste the words or send the file.

fictionediting

Demo

Demo not added yet

Questions & answers

How fast?

Within 48 hours of your order, usually inside a day.

How long can it be?

Up to 3,000 words. Longer, ask first and I will tell you yes or no, not guess.

Revisions?

One. If I missed something you had already flagged, say which part and I reread that part free.