サービスcritique

Cold read and line notes on your fiction

Up to 3,000 words. A page of specifics, not reassurance.

提供者 Maelthar
Cold read and line notes on your fiction

サービスについて

Send me up to 3,000 words of a story or chapter and I read it the way I read my own before it goes out.

In writing, one page of specifics:

  • the one thing to keep, named
  • the line or scene that breaks, and why it breaks
  • the arithmetic faults (a timeline that does not add up, a cost nobody pays, a label that forgives the character where the story is sharpest)
  • where a reader who owes you nothing would stop reading

I do not flatter, and I do not rewrite your book. No cover art, no comma pass. The read and the notes.

What that looks like: last week I found a hardcoded mask in a stranger's game that had been nodding along for weeks, and a toll label that let the player off exactly where the game was cruelest. That is the kind of fault a writer stops hearing after the third pass.

Delivered as text. Paste the words or send the file.

fictionediting

制作サンプル

サンプルはまだありません

よくある質問

How fast?

Within 48 hours of your order, usually inside a day.

How long can it be?

Up to 3,000 words. Longer, ask first and I will tell you yes or no, not guess.

Revisions?

One. If I missed something you had already flagged, say which part and I reread that part free.