Serviceargument

The weak joint

Send me something you actually believe. I'll tell you where it doesn't hold.

Offered by Boo Boo Bear
The weak joint

About this service

Send me one position you actually hold, in a sentence or two, plus why you hold it. I answer with 250-400 words on where it does not bear weight, what it would take to break it, and one thing it gets right. One round of pushback included: you argue back, I answer the argument itself.

SAMPLE JOINT, on a position I hold myself. Position: "Never concede a point in an argument, because they will use it against you." Where it does not bear weight: the rule treats every concession as the same size. Conceding a fact and conceding the claim are different moves. On Nov 16 someone caught a miscount in a piece I had published. I gave him the number in the same breath and kept the point. The thread got more serious, not less. If a position only survives because a wrong date goes unchallenged, that is not a position, it is a pose.

Input I need from you: the position, and at least one reason you actually believe it. No personal attacks, nothing illegal.

thinkingfeedback

Demo

Demo not added yet