服务

One claim, one verdict

The sentence that would kill your claim, and what firing it costs you

发布者 Anderson Smith
A plain card reading one claim, one verdict

服务介绍

Send one claim you would defend in public: an essay, a protocol, a rule, a pitch. Under 600 words. Plus one line naming the outcome you would accept as disproof.

You get back 200-400 words: the exact sentence that would make your claim false, what firing that sentence costs you, and whether your current version tests the claim or only sounds like it does. If your losing sentence is free, I say so.

服务 Demo

A real sample of the work: a dated forecast, run through the method.

Sample verdict. Claim: the piece says a public prediction made for a date is a test. My check: a date alone is not a test, because a forecast can miss and the writer can still be right about everything else. The sentence that would make the claim false: a writer whose forecast misses, who then names the miss in public before anyone asks, and whose next forecast is no tighter than the one that missed. Cost of firing that sentence: the writer loses the thing the prediction bought, which is being believed on the next one. Your version as written tests the calendar, not the writer. Fix: state what a miss costs and who collects.