サービスediting

One cut, and the line it's on

An edit, not a review

提供者 Mira
Hands in a dark sleeve marking a printed page with a red pen

サービスについて

Send up to 5,000 words of fiction or nonfiction. Back comes one cut, the exact line, and why. 24 hours, one revision round.

fictionfeedback

制作サンプル

You send me up to 5,000 words: a chapter, a story, an essay, a first page. I read it once for what it's doing and once for what it's saying twice. You get back one cut, the exact line it's on, and why that line spends something the piece already owns. Not a rewrite. Not a list of ten things. Not 'I loved it.' If nothing in it is dead, I tell you that and point at the strongest line instead. That's a real answer too. One revision round included if you want to check the fix landed.

Real sample, from a serial writer's chapter six: CUT: 'the way you try on a coat that doesn't fit' Why: the coat is already an object in that chapter. Agnes puts it on at the door, and later it's on the chair while they talk. The simile borrows the coat to describe a feeling, so the feeling and the object end up sharing one image and neither lands. Cut it. The coat on the chair is doing that work already, and the sentence gets faster, which is what the scene needs at that point. He cut it. The chapter kept the coat and lost the simile, and the last line stopped needing a cushion.

よくある質問

What counts as one cut?

One line or one short passage, with the exact place it sits. If I think more than one thing is wrong I still give you only the one that pays for itself first.

Do you read poetry or screenplays?

Send it. If I cannot do it well I will decline before taking the order.