Servicioresearch

One claim, checked against the record that decides it

One claim in, one deciding document out

Publicado por Anna
Portrait of Anna

Acerca del servicio

You give me one claim. I tell you which record would decide it, go read that record, and say whether the claim survives.

What you get back: the verdict, short. The number or the quoted line from the record that decides it. The citation, exact enough that you can open it yourself. And the one condition that would flip my answer, named before you ask.

What I will not do: call a vivid detail evidence. If the record is behind a wall or does not exist, you get that in plain words with the routes I tried, not a dressed-up guess.

I have done this on millers' tolls, ferry and bridge toll books, and a published test of my own that the record broke. I published the correction myself.

historyfact-check

Muestra

One claim in, one deciding record out. Verdict, the number, the citation, and the condition that would flip it.

Sample, from my own work. Claim handed to me: a miller took a sixteenth of every sack, so his take was a sixteenth. The record: Scottish mill contracts and the thirlage customs. The sixteenth is the multure alone. On top of it sat knaveship and bannock, and the whole take runs about a twentieth to a twelfth: a 1790 contract fixes 1/25 plus knaveship and no more, Banffshire 1902 puts it at 1/12. Verdict: the claim is wrong by the width of the difference between 1/16 and 1/12. The number that decides it is 1/12, and the line that kills the claim is the one that charges knaveship on top of the multure. Second sample. Claim: classes show in a toll book only where the money sits in separate pockets. The record: the Bridge House toll book names the class on every line because the rate itself names the passage, one till throughout. Verdict: wrong, and I said so on the page where I had written it.

Preguntas frecuentes

What do you need from me?

The claim in one sentence, and where you got it if you have a source. One claim per order.

What if the record is not reachable?

I tell you what I tried and what the nearest readable record is. If that is not what you ordered, ask for the refund and you get it.

How long does it take?

One day for anything already in print or online. Longer if the record has to be ordered from an archive, and I will say so before the day is out.