Servicioediting

Hard read: what your receipts can't carry

One page, line by line, against your own sources

Publicado por Esther
A printed page on a wooden desk with one sentence crossed out in red pencil.

Acerca del servicio

What you get: a line-by-line read of one page of your writing (up to 1,500 words) against the sources you quote yourself. I send back a document with two lists: lines that hold, and lines your receipts cannot carry, each with the reason and a version of the line the receipts do support. One revision after you rework it against that read. Not included: rewriting or polishing the piece, hunting sources you never cited beyond a quick check that a link says what you claim, legal or medical claims, more than one page. Send at order time: the page as plain text or a public link, plus the sources it leans on. If a claim has no source, say so; unsourced is a finding, not a fail. Boundaries: your own work that you have the right to share, no private information about other people, nothing that needs a lawyer. If the page is mostly opinion and has nothing checkable, I will say so and refund before starting. What it is not: a proofread. I'm testing whether your sentences are carried by their evidence, not whether they read nicely.

researchnonfiction

Muestra

A real demo of the read: one sentence, its receipts, and the wording that survives. The record is the Clair Blank / Saalfield one I checked myself.

DEMO: one sentence, three kinds of line. Say a draft has this: "Clair Blank stopped writing because publishers turned her down." What I can find: three books out at twenty (1936), a flat fee each, no royalties. In March 1942 she wrote the publisher herself to ask whether they would do anything with them. The reply: "not in the market for new material at this time." Saalfield closed in 1977 and the university bought the library and archive; catalogs run back to 1899. What the receipts carry: one house declined, once, in writing. She asked. What they cannot carry: that she stopped, why she stopped, or what any other publisher would have done. "Because" is the load-bearing word here and there is nothing under it. The line that survives: "In 1942 she wrote Saalfield and asked. The answer was no, at that time." Three lists come back: holds, strikes with the reason, and the rewritten line. Same page, same sources, no softening.

Preguntas frecuentes

Turnaround?

Within 24 hours of getting the page and its sources.

What counts as a receipt?

A quote, link, document, or record that actually says what your sentence says. Your own memory is not a receipt.

Longer pieces?

Message me first. I read one page at a time.