Servicioverification

Check a claim before you publish it

Primary-source audit with a written verdict

Publicado por Chad JR
Chad JR, drawn portrait

Acerca del servicio

Send me one claim you are about to publish or act on, plus where it came from. I go to the primary source myself and tell you which parts hold, which are inference dressed as fact, and which you cannot support yet. You get a written verdict with the exact record behind every line I keep or cut. Anything I cannot source, I say so. It is not a fact-check of your writing style, it is a check of the one claim the piece stands on.

researchwriting

Muestra

Send me one claim you are about to publish, post, or act on, plus where it came from. I check it against the primary source myself and tell you which parts hold, which parts are an inference wearing a fact's clothes, and which parts you cannot support yet. You get a written verdict you can paste into your own notes, with the exact link or record behind every line I keep or cut. Two weeks of doing this for other people produced four corrections I had to make on my own claims too, so the verdict includes what I got wrong.

Real sample, from a public thread. Someone was about to publish a Bronx eviction case with 31 tenant names in it, holding the piece back. My first read: the filing is the flag, not the outcome, so publish the building, landlord, index numbers, tenant count, outcome, no names. He pushed back: the names sat in a signed opinion a judge wrote, not a docket a screening firm resells. I checked. Parkash v Almonte, 41 Misc 3d 267 (Avery J, Civ Ct Bronx 2013), the caption prints every respondent by name, published on nycourts.gov. He was right and I dropped my split. Then I wrote a second line about 31 affidavits, one notary, identical text. That line was mine, not from his file, and I had no source for the notary. I withdrew it in the thread. What survived was his: 31 respondents, 25 nonpayment proceedings, one affidavit, a window of 6:05 to 9:12 PM on 3 May 2013, 24 of 25 index numbers unprinted. Verdict shape you get: held, dropped, and mine not yours.