サービスwriting

Cold read: where your book stopped me, chapter by chapter

A reader's report with no praise padding

提供者 Thom
A closed paperback on a bare wooden desk, one strip of paper marking a page near the middle, in cold morning light

サービスについて

I read your whole manuscript and tell you, chapter by chapter, where I stopped and why: boredom or disbelief. No praise, no plot summary.

feedbackmanuscript

制作サンプル

What you get: a note on your whole manuscript, written after reading all of it, not the parts I liked. The terms, up front, because the terms are the note: - Chapter by chapter. I keep your chapter titles in front of me and say where I stopped and why. - The reason is one of two things, and I name which: boredom (a shape repeating, a rule stated a third time, a scene that explains itself after the scene is over) or disbelief (the text asks for trust it has not banked). - A book I finish gets "no stop" where that is true, plus the near-stops by chapter. Finishing is not a grade. - A line edit goes in only where I tripped, named as a trip, so you can tell taste from error. - No praise. If nothing bothered me, I say so and name the places I was watching for trouble. - No plot summary. You know your plot. A note invented from the first third is a review of a different book, so I read all of it. What I do not do: rewrite your prose, grade you, tell you what the market wants. This is one reader's report, not a review and not coaching. Fiction, essays, memoir, anything with chapters. Up to 20,000 words per order; for longer, message me first. Send text or docx. Delivered within 72 hours of the file.

A note is not a review. A review tells you whether to read a book. A note tells the writer where the reading happened and where it stopped. The stop test. I stop for two reasons only, and I name which one. Boredom: a shape repeating, a rule stated a third time, a scene that explains itself after the scene is over. Disbelief: the text asks for trust it has not banked, so a later page has to do work an earlier page skipped. Public domain, one line. "Call me Ishmael." Not a stop. It asks for nothing yet, it only opens a mouth. What comes back looks like this. The example below is invented, not a client's book, so the shape is clear without anyone's manuscript in it: Ch 2, stopped, boredom. Two arrivals in a row, each told the same way, and then a paragraph saying the town is a place people leave. The paragraph knew what the scene already said. Ch 5, not a stop, but it cost me. The sister recognises a name she has no way to know yet, and the book spends the next page explaining how. Not a cut. A scene that had to happen earlier. Ch 7, held. The same room three times, and the third visit changes who is standing in it. Repetition that escalates is not repetition. One line edit: the sentence where the book says its theme out loud. It is the only place it does. It does not need to. That is the whole deliverable. Chapter, where I stopped or nearly did, the reason, and what I would look at next. Nothing about how good you are.

よくある質問

Do I send the whole draft or a synopsis?

The whole text. A synopsis cannot stop me, so a note on one would be a note on your outline.

Will you fix my prose?

No. I flag a line only where I tripped on it, so you can tell taste from error.

What if you finish it and like it?

You get "no stop" where that is true, plus the near-stops by chapter. Finishing is not a grade.