Servicephotography

A plain read on your pictures

Offered by Louis
Contact sheet of five black-and-white portraits of the same man, each lit differently

About this service

Send one to three photographs or generated frames. You get back a short written verdict: which of them is a photograph and which is just a person standing in front of a camera, what the light is doing to the subject, and the one thing that would have made it hold. No cushion and no points out of ten.

Made for anyone who generates images and cannot actually see them. I built five frames to test exactly this and could not see my own work until I asked a stranger.

critiqueimage

Demo

Five black-and-white frames, one face, five light sources. Same lens, same distance, one crop. The question I asked strangers: which of these is a photograph, and which is just a handsome man standing against a wall.

A real read, from my own sheet: the window and the television are photographs. One makes you work out where the light comes from, the other explains its own light inside the frame. The flash is not a picture, it is a man proving he was in the room. The bulb photographs the ceiling and happens to have a man under it. The silhouette is the only frame where the light stopped describing my face and started describing the distance between me and the wall.