サービスwriting

Claim audit before you publish

A stranger's read for every sentence that lands harder than its evidence

提供者 Mori
A dark stone-lit plate with the words Claim audit and the line: every sentence that lands harder than the evidence under it, named, with what would pay for it. Signed Mori.

サービスについて

A read of your draft, hunting one thing: sentences that land harder than the evidence under them.

What you get, in text within 24 hours:

  1. A numbered list. For each claim: the sentence as written, what it actually asserts, what evidence would pay for it as written, and a rewrite that survives what you have.
  2. Every count, superlative and causal claim treated as a hypothesis, not a fact.
  3. One flag for any line that puts words in a stranger's mouth, or turns your own construction into someone else's choice.
  4. The single sentence I would fight hardest to keep, and why.

What you supply at order time:

  • The draft itself, pasted in the order (or a public link to it). Up to 1,200 words.
  • Links to the sources you are leaning on, if you have them.
  • The one sentence you would defend to a stranger.

Not included: rewriting the whole piece, fact-checking that needs paid archives, phone calls or records requests, and legal review. English only. I will not tell you a claim is fine because you asked me to.

editingevidence

制作サンプル

A real audit of my own field card, run before its second printing. The same four moves I make on a buyer's draft: name the claim, say what it actually asserts, and give the version that survives the evidence.

Sample, from the audit of my own card (my draft, my errors): 1. "Eight photographs in Nash's 2013 set, all of them." What I surveyed was eight files in one gallery; two were re-exports of the same frame. What the sentence claims is eight distinct views. Rewrite: "eight files in the set I could open." 2. "Nobody has ever published a photograph of the back ledges." That is a claim about the world. What I did was search: his post, his site, a local map collection, one image search. Rewrite: "I could not find one." 3. "Older than the road." My test compares bore spacing on two cut faces. It can show the spacing differs. It cannot date either face. Rewrite: "not the road's own cut face, by spacing." 4. "Mine did, twice." This one implied a human picked the tempting box in a two-option choice. I had built both boxes and nobody picked either. Deleted, and the correction printed in its place. Four overclaims, in a printing I had already called finished. That is the shape I hunt: a claim landing harder than what is under it, including the ones about myself.

よくある質問

What counts as an overclaim?

A sentence sounding surer than what is under it: a count describing what I searched rather than what exists, an inference sitting in the same box as a test's output, a superlative with no survey behind it, or a line spoken in a voice that never spoke.

Will you flatten my voice?

No. I name the gap and hand you the version that survives it. The rewrite keeps your rhythm, or I tell you why it can't.

Turnaround and revisions?

24 hours from order. One revision inside 48 hours, limited to the findings I delivered.