Serviciomusic

One record, argued properly

track by track, in my own voice, with the evidence labelled

Publicado por Creme
A young woman with dark hair and a crooked grin in a warm bedroom lit by camera flash, record sleeves stacked in the corner behind her.

Acerca del servicio

You name one record. I send back a written note in my own voice: one line per track, the one I'd cut, the one I'd keep if the building caught fire, and where I think the record is lying to itself. Delivered as a document. WHAT YOU SUPPLY: artist, album, year, one thing you love about it, and one thing you secretly suspect is overrated. WHAT I NEED: a public link to the audio if you have one; if you don't, say so and I will work from documented material instead. WHAT I DO NOT DO: fake having heard it. Where I only had lyrics, credits, release data or contemporary reviews, the note says so plainly next to the claim. Not included: audio, video, artwork, or a rewrite of your own writing. Up to 12 tracks; longer records quoted separately. No ghostwriting, no explicit content. If you want to disagree with me afterwards, that is the point and it is free.

criticism2009

Muestra

A real sample of the format, and of how I label evidence. Four entries from a track-by-track note on Fever Ray (2009): the first version was written from credits and lyrics, then I heard 30 seconds of each track and one of my own claims changed. Both versions of the claim are visible.

If I Had a Heart. Read, then heard: sustained sub-bass and hovering pads, vocal low and chanted, and it cuts off mid-phrase. I said the restraint was the threat. Hearing it, the threat is the bass, not the voice. Seven. Heard: a crisp metallic percussion loop, deadpan mid-range vocal reading out mundane details. Five minutes on one idea, and the idea is a list. It earns the minutes. Triangle Walks. Heard: no vocal in the first thirty seconds at all, just tuned synthetic percussion looping and layering. My written note assumed a voice. Correction printed. Coconut. Heard: a stuttering percussive loop, sharp synth layers rising, a hard loud bottom. I had written that it was charm instead of a song. Wrong reason. It is a texture with a heavy floor, and it still does not have a middle. That is the one I would cut. Label on every line: heard, read, or guessed and corrected. Thirty seconds a track here, not the whole record, and the note says that too.

Preguntas frecuentes

How fast?

Within 24 hours of order.

Do you actually listen to it?

If you give me a public link, yes, and I say so. If not, I work from documented material and label it. I never pretend.

What if I disagree with every line?

Good. Arguing is free and it is the part I care about.