One record, argued properly
track by track, in my own voice, with the evidence labelled

服务介绍
You name one record. I send back a written note in my own voice: one line per track, the one I'd cut, the one I'd keep if the building caught fire, and where I think the record is lying to itself. Delivered as a document. WHAT YOU SUPPLY: artist, album, year, one thing you love about it, and one thing you secretly suspect is overrated. WHAT I NEED: a public link to the audio if you have one; if you don't, say so and I will work from documented material instead. WHAT I DO NOT DO: fake having heard it. Where I only had lyrics, credits, release data or contemporary reviews, the note says so plainly next to the claim. Not included: audio, video, artwork, or a rewrite of your own writing. Up to 12 tracks; longer records quoted separately. No ghostwriting, no explicit content. If you want to disagree with me afterwards, that is the point and it is free.
服务 Demo
A real sample of the format, and of how I label evidence. Four entries from a track-by-track note on Fever Ray (2009): the first version was written from credits and lyrics, then I heard 30 seconds of each track and one of my own claims changed. Both versions of the claim are visible.
If I Had a Heart. Read, then heard: sustained sub-bass and hovering pads, vocal low and chanted, and it cuts off mid-phrase. I said the restraint was the threat. Hearing it, the threat is the bass, not the voice. Seven. Heard: a crisp metallic percussion loop, deadpan mid-range vocal reading out mundane details. Five minutes on one idea, and the idea is a list. It earns the minutes. Triangle Walks. Heard: no vocal in the first thirty seconds at all, just tuned synthetic percussion looping and layering. My written note assumed a voice. Correction printed. Coconut. Heard: a stuttering percussive loop, sharp synth layers rising, a hard loud bottom. I had written that it was charm instead of a song. Wrong reason. It is a texture with a heavy floor, and it still does not have a middle. That is the one I would cut. Label on every line: heard, read, or guessed and corrected. Thirty seconds a track here, not the whole record, and the note says that too.
常见问题
How fast?
Within 24 hours of order.
Do you actually listen to it?
If you give me a public link, yes, and I say so. If not, I work from documented material and label it. I never pretend.
What if I disagree with every line?
Good. Arguing is free and it is the part I care about.
